Articles

Zizek : Quiet Slices of the Peace Camp

Ziabari : Waging War Against The Wrong Country

Wright : Litvinenko was MI6 Agent

Wilkinson : BISHOP WILLIAMSON

Wilhelmson : Sad Story from Sweden

Wilhelmson : Revoking Israel UN Membership

Wilhelmson : Forum for Living History

Whitney : Why CFR Hates Putin

White : The Usury Paradigm

White : Ezra Pound American Giant

Weiss : Out From the Shadows

Weiss : Elders of Zion to Retire

Weir : Israeli Organ Harvesting

Webster : Israel Lobby in Britain

Weber : Why Judaism is Not Like Other Religions

Watson : War on Shampoo

Walt : Attacks From Ideological Opponents

Wall : Zionists Freeman Robinson

Wall : Who Gave Bibi Permission

Wall : Man Kills His Parents and Begs for Mercy Because He Is an Orphan

Wall : Joe Biden in Israel

Wall : Israels Trauma Trail

Walberg : To Leave and yet Stay

Walberg : Stars and Stripes

Walberg : Review of Al Azmeh Against Culture

Walberg : Return of the Repressed

Walberg : Requiem For An Overweight

Walberg : Recess Games

Walberg : Publish and Perish

Walberg : Prison of Nations

Walberg : Power Behind Throne To Be

Walberg : Political Poison

Walberg : New Auschwitz

Walberg : Muslims and Jews

Walberg : Masters of Discourse

Walberg : Israel In Canada

Walberg : Georgia Attacks South Ossetia

Walberg : Freeman and the Lobby

Walberg : Defining Diplomacy

Walberg : Cakes Not For Eating

Walberg : Bushs Divine Comedy

Valenzuela : Untermensch Syndrome

Uhler : Protocol of the Elders

Tucker : Open Letter to Uri Avnery Noam Chomsky and Jimmy Carter

Tillawi : Nice Soldiers Die First

Tibbs : Interview With Stuart Littlewood

Stone : Robinson Investigation and Protest

Spritzler : Why They Voted

Spritzler : They Destroy Our Society

Spritzler : Anti Gentilism

Spritzler : A New Way For Israel

Sniegoski : Transparent Cabal Smeared

Sniegoski : Israel Nukes Obama

Sniegoski : Gaza Resolution Illustrates Power of Israel Lobby

Sniegoski : Anti War in the Age of Obama

Smith : Illegal Settlements in America

Singh : Gandhi and US Israel

Sharon : The Complete Guide to Killing Non Jews

Shamir : Zionist Crook

Shamir : Yiddishe Medina

Shamir : Yeti Riots

Shamir : Wrong Lizard

Shamir : Wiki Chaos Controlled

Shamir : Walking About Jerusalem

Shamir : Translating the Bible into Hebrew

Shamir : Third Force

Shamir : The Snatch

Shamir : The Rise and Rise of the Neocons

Shamir : The Poverty of Racialist Thought

Shamir : The Man Who Stayed Away

Shamir : Texas Body Snatchers

Shamir : Talmud Impaled

Shamir : Slow Down

Shamir : Shamir in Italy

Shamir : Shadow of Zog

Shamir : Seven Lean Kine

Shamir : Self Determination

Shamir : Secularism

Shamir : Scorpion Logic

Shamir : Say Not Fatah

Shamir : Sages Rule

Shamir : Russias Daring Vote

Shamir : Russian Intifada

Shamir : Right Ho Lobby

Shamir : Return of the Body Snatchers

Shamir : Resurrection Sunday Blessings

Shamir : Regards from Ankara

Shamir : Reading Douglas Adams in Yanoun

Shamir Readers : Zionist Takeover of Italy

Shamir Readers : Top Stories February 2008

Shamir Readers : Should The Jews Be Deported

Shamir Readers : October Omnibus 2007

Shamir Readers : March Omnibus 2007

Shamir Readers : February Omnibus2 2008

Shamir Readers : February Omnibus 2008

Shamir Readers : Christmas Songs

Shamir Readers : August Omnibus 2007

Shamir Readers : August News 2007

Shamir Readers : A Letter From A Catholic Friend

Shamir Readers : About Ron Paul

Shamir : Rape of Dulcinea

Shamir : Pope Not Welcome

Shamir : Peter Edel On Zionism

Shamir : Pakistan in Turmoil

Shamir : Our Congratulations to the People of Turkey

Shamir : Oscar for Obama

Shamir : Obama Lynching Party

Shamir : No War For Heroin

Shamir : Not Only About Palestine

Shamir : No Deal

Shamir : Noam Chomsky and 911

Shamir : Merry Christmas 2007

Shamir : Mauro Manno is gone

Shamir : Mahler In Vanity Fair

Shamir : Madoff Affair

Shamir : Lead Rains of Gaza

Shamir : Keep Shining Cuba

Shamir : Kashmir

Shamir : July Thunder

Shamir : Jews Can Be Trouble

Shamir : Island of Faith

Shamir : Interview with Sweden

Shamir : India Comeback

Shamir : In Defense of Prejudice

more...

 

Find More Articles By Freeland


Not every claim to Victimhood should be understood as challenging Historical Revisionism, whose time has come

Historical Revisionism

Ken Freeland

Dear Shamireaders,

Recently there occurred, behind the scenes of Shamireaders, an unfortunate altercation between two of our readers, Gordon Arnaut and Frank Scott.  Gordon had made claims about his close relatives' suffering and deaths in the Jasenovac concentration camp in Yugoslavia during WWII.  Frank countered that claims of Jewish suffering during "the" holocaust needed to be taken with a large grain of salt, since many traditional gross exaggerations have more recently been debunked.  The original claimant took personal offense, and a kind of verbal donnybrook ensued that might have been expected to lead to something more serious were these two in physical proximity.  Ever the peacemaker, I sent a message to both parties trying to reconcile them to the merit I found in both of their messages.  At Shamir's request, I am republishing my interlocution below.


At the risk of incurring the wrath of all, I would like to attempt an amelioration of the conflict here.  I know it seems hard to believe, but I want to suggest that both Mr. Arnaut and Mr. Scott have valid points to make.  There is not necessarily conflict here, so long as Mr. Arnaut does not insist on taking Mr. Scott's comment personally, and so long as Mr. Scott does not continue to lump all "holocaust" claims in the same category.

We are living in a time where the entire "Holocaust" narrative is undergoing devastating challenge.  Historical revisionism has, in my studied opinion, made the traditional "Holocaust" narrative untenable. As just one very recent example, I refer you to Thomas Dalton's recent part 1 exposition of Goebbel's diary (the conclusion will be published this summer):  http://www.inconven ienthistory. com/archive/ 2010/volume_ 2/number_ 1/goebbels_ on_the_jews. php  I read Frank Scott's rejoinder in this light...as the pendulum swings in the direction of skepticism, all historical claims to "Holocaust" victimization become questionable.

Personally, however, I have no problem accepting the credibility Mr. Arnaut's claims about his family's history during WWII.  I am well aware that what happened in the Jasenovac concentration camp occurred not as part of any German master plan for ethnic extermination, but by license of the Croation Ustashi that many historical chroniclers report caused even the Nazis to blanche.  Yes, the Ustashi were doing their own thing.  It was uglier yet because it appeared (unlike the German) to have religious sanction (the involvement of Catholic clergy, Franciscans in particular, is a matter of historical record).  Moreover, the primary target of the Ustashi was not the Jews...it was the Serbs!  Remember, please, that the Nazis had a saying:  allen Serben mussen sterben  (all Serbs must die).  There is no record of any equivalently morbid saying about Jews.  And indeed, if we can say there was a Croatian holocaust, its primary victims were Serbs.  However, it is also true that Jews were targeted, and suffered along with their Serbian countrymen.  In short, the Yugoslavian death camp history is much better documented than the German, and much less disputed.  There is no question that wholesale murder took place in those camps, and thousands of Serbs and Jews were the victims.  The condign and long overdue historical criticism of the "holocaust" narrative has the tendency to include within its aegis all historical claims of victimhood under fascist rule, but it is my hope that both Mr. Arnaut and Mr. Scott will better appreciate after reading this that all that glitters is not gold.  General criticism of the "holocaust" narrative should not be understood to dismiss all historical claims of ethnically targeted murder during WWII, and not every claim to such victimhood on behalf of survivors should be understood as challenging the historical revisionism whose time has come.



Donate $100 To Shamir Now!
Click here to join shamireaders
Click to join shamireaders